Nichtoffener Wettbewerb | 07/2013
Neuer Campus der Vietnamesisch-Deutschen Universität / New Campus of the Vietnamese-German University
3. Preis
Architektur
Tragwerksplanung
P.T. Morimura & Associates Ltd.
Bauingenieurwesen
Lichtplanung
T.C.L. Taylor Cullity Lethlean
Landschaftsarchitektur
Akustikplanung
Beurteilung durch das Preisgericht
Applying the criteria of the RFP, the jury appreciated the project for the following qualities:
Strong concept, modest at the same time as providing identity.
Applying the criteria of the RFP, the following components of the project have been judged as less successful by the jury:
The phasing concept for the main building has been identified as a main flaw of the concept, creating the need for most of the infrastructure to be undertaken at the 1st phase.
Location of special functions around the central building are highlighted, but create weak connections and a lack of integration.
Isolation of administration.
Confusing formal organization of student accommodation buildings.
Applying the criteria of the RFP, the jury has doubts in regard of the following parts of the design, resulting in the recommendation to review these elements in case the authors are chosen for further development:
A clearer description of how the construction phasing and occupancy would take place, as the current arrangement does not seem feasible.
Strong concept, modest at the same time as providing identity.
Applying the criteria of the RFP, the following components of the project have been judged as less successful by the jury:
The phasing concept for the main building has been identified as a main flaw of the concept, creating the need for most of the infrastructure to be undertaken at the 1st phase.
Location of special functions around the central building are highlighted, but create weak connections and a lack of integration.
Isolation of administration.
Confusing formal organization of student accommodation buildings.
Applying the criteria of the RFP, the jury has doubts in regard of the following parts of the design, resulting in the recommendation to review these elements in case the authors are chosen for further development:
A clearer description of how the construction phasing and occupancy would take place, as the current arrangement does not seem feasible.